Chapter 3: Choosing and Developing Your Topic
The Complete Short Story Writing Textbook for Beginners
If you’d prefer to get all chapters at once, download the ebook (PDF) version of
The Complete Short Story Writing Textbook for Beginners
Hey writers,
Hope you nailed last week’s theme exercise. If you wrote down a plot/theme pair for a story idea, you’re already ahead of 90% of beginners. (Share yours in the comments if you want feedback!)
Today we tackle a classic piece of advice that’s widely misunderstood: “Write what you know.”
Most people hear this and think, “I can’t write about astronauts because I’m an accountant.” Wrong.
This post will show you what that really means and how to find story gold in your own life without writing an autobiography.
“Write What You Know” – The Misunderstood Advice
You’ve probably heard: “Write what you know.”
Many take this literally:
“I’m a teacher. Does that mean I should only write about teachers?”
‘I’ve never been to war, so I can’t write about soldiers.’
This is too narrow.
“Write what you know” really means: Write what you know emotionally.
You may not know what it’s like to be:
A firefighter entering a burning building.
A politician making a public statement.
But you do know:
Fear
Shame
Guilt
Love
Envy
Responsibility
If you understand the emotion, you can build believable fiction around it.
Mining Your Emotional Memory
Strong stories begin in emotional truth.
Think back to times in your life when you:
Felt deeply wronged
Were embarrassed in front of others
Were desperate to be chosen, forgiven, or loved
Felt responsible for someone else’s wellbeing
Did something you regret
For one of these memories, write:
What happened (briefly)
How it affected you over the next hours, days, or weeks
Notice:
Emotions are rarely clean or linear.
Anger hides hurt. Shame hides fear. Relief hides guilt.
That complexity is what makes fiction feel alive.
Common Topics, Uncommon Treatment
You don’t need a wildly original subject.
Great stories are often about:
Love
Loss
Family tensions
Friendships
Illness
Money
Work
What makes them powerful is not what they’re about but how they’re told:
The voice
The details chosen
The perspective
The tone (dark, comic, detached, intimate)
Two writers can both write about, say, divorce:
One with dark bitterness
One with absurd humor
Same topic, completely different stories.
Narrowing Your Focus
“Grief” is too broad.
“Marriage” is too broad.
Short stories thrive on specific situations:
“A father tries to explain to his child why the family is moving away.”
“Two siblings clean out their late mother’s house and argue over what to keep.”
“A woman sees her teenage bully again by chance, twenty years later.”
Ask yourself:
What single moment could carry the weight of this theme?
What event forces my character to face what they usually avoid?
Questions to Choose a Story-Worthy Moment
What is a moment when your character’s self-image is challenged?
When do they have to choose between two things they care about?
When do they realize something they cannot un-realize?
When do they lose something they can never get back?
Pick one such moment. That’s a great starting point for a short story.
Exercise: From Theme to Scene
Choose a theme: e.g., “Fear of abandonment” or “The cost of ambition.”
Write down three concrete situations that could express this theme.
Example for “fear of abandonment”:A child waits at school pickup and their parent is late.
A lover reads a text that suggests their partner may leave.
An elderly person realizes their children are too busy to visit.
Pick the one that feels most alive to you and build from
This Chapter’s Action Step
Take 15 minutes today.
Pick one emotional memory from your life (the more specific, the better).
Write 3-5 sentences about it.
Transform it into a fictional scene by changing the names, jobs and setting, while maintaining the emotional truth.
Example:
Real life: “My boss ignored my presentation.”
Story scene: “The surgeon watched the chief resident skip over her proposal during rounds.”
Share your before/after in the comments!
What’s Next?
In the next chapter: Building unforgettable characters—the single most important skill for short story success. You’ll learn how to create a “character bible” that makes your people feel real in just a few pages.
Questions about turning emotions into fiction? Hit the comments.
See you next time!
P.S. The best stories aren’t about astronauts or spies. They’re about what it feels like to be human. You’ve got more material than you think.
If you found this helpful, please like ❤️ and share it with a writer friend.
Eventually, you could buy me a coffee to help me concentrate better when writing the next chapters.
Thank you for reading! I hope you find this helpful!